For years and even before I was a painting contractor I was aware of polyester fillers…the main one being Bondo. I used it to repair all the dents and dings in my extended ego (read car) in high school and college. When I started painting, of course I began using it and other brands of similar formulations on homes and came to find that what is good for thin repairs on a car may not be good for a thin repair on the siding of a ship-lap sided home. After a few months in the sun, I was back removing the remainder of what the sun had not de-laminated for me. The problem was that polyester filler is not formulated to do two things very well: adhere nor flex with wood substrates…lesson learned. I do keep polyester filler in the truck though, as it does work well for effective interior repairs to heavily damaged lock-sets and dead-bolts that have been blown out. It dries super-fast especially so because you can “goose” it with extra catalyst. On the other hand there is epoxy which you cannot “goose” with extra catalyst or you will really screw it up. Epoxies are each uniquely formulated to a specific dry time and thickness/viscosity as well as dry flexibility properties and adhesion and they do adhere! Most of these are overnight dry which is why painters who don’t give a hoot for quality of the repair rely too heavily on Bondo so it will cure in 2 minutes and they can get home to beer and Oprah while the repair fails as soon as the check clears. Various epoxies are made for craftsmen and proper wood repairs should be in your tool box. Here are a few I always have on hand:
Now with any repair: the wet, feathery, lignin-free wood needs to be gotten rid of. Like a dentist, you have to use whatever tool: a drill, chisel, 5-1 and get that bad wood out. I then drill pilot holes all around the repair and in the sides and base at an angle and soak the surrounding wood with consolidator (see Smith’s Epoxy below) which is often sold by the epoxy manufacturer and can be a very thin epoxy itself that plasticizes the wood or an very thin acrylic that chases water and impregnates with hardening in the wood. Note: after the repair is totally complete I will go just outside it and drill ¼” holes where water might get in again and insert boric acid pellets so that they will disperse into the wood and prevent rot if water should ever enter. Also use a polyurethane caulk like Vulkem (oil based) at upper facing seams that could open up in the future…sure it takes a few days to dry and you cannot paint it “in minutes” but aren’t “time saving” products like cheap caulk that you can “paint in minutes” what cause premature failure in the end? Shoot…if you are going to be using a $45 tube or can of epoxy…sell yourself, do it right, sleep at night and be a craftsman
Hope these tips and products will help you